Bounce Rate Investigation: Uncovering $120K+ in Annual Ad Savings
What looked like a product issue turned out to be a traffic quality failure — and a massive opportunity.
The Illusion: Bounce Rates at 50–70% Across Core Pages
Alarming Bounce Rate Spikes
Bounce rates suddenly spiking to 70%+ across core landing pages, significantly above industry benchmarks.
False UX Problem Narrative
Metrics painted a convincing but ultimately false story about serious user experience issues on the site.
Campaign Performance Concerns
Raised serious alarms about the effectiveness and ROI of our paid acquisition campaigns.
Elusive Pattern Recognition
No clear pattern emerged from surface-level analysis—until we conducted a deeper, more segmented investigation.
The Investigation Begins
Segment by Traffic Source
Breaking down anomalous bounce rates across all major traffic channels to identify patterns and isolate problematic segments.
Isolate the Outlier
Discovered one massive outlier: "(not set)" traffic showing nearly 100% bounce rate across most periods.
Correlation Analysis
Volume of "(not set)" traffic correlated perfectly with overall bounce rate spikes — our smoking gun.
The "(not set)" segment towered over legitimate traffic sources with extreme bounce rates, immediately flagging it as suspicious and pointing to our root cause.
Unmasking the Culprit
Untraceable Origin
Traffic lacked any identifiable source/medium parameters, appearing as "(not set)" in analytics reports.
Channel Classification Failure
GA4 couldn't assign these sessions to any standard channel grouping, creating a data black hole.
Zero Engagement Metrics
Sessions showed near-zero page depth, time on site, or any meaningful interaction patterns.
Temporal Pattern
Traffic peaked dramatically pre-April, then mysteriously vanished—coinciding with campaign changes.
The Proof — Spam vs. Real Users
Key Insight: When "(not set)" traffic disappeared in early April, bounce rates instantly normalized across all pages—providing definitive proof of its illegitimate nature.
Timeline to Resolution
1
Early March
Identified abnormal bounce rate patterns across core landing pages, reaching 70%+ in some instances.
2
March 7
Paused brand keyword bidding as first diagnostic test, resulting in slight bounce rate reduction.
3
Late March
Paused Performance Max campaigns, after which major traffic spikes began to disappear from analytics.
4
April 1-3
Bounce rates plunged across entire site, confirming suspicions about fraudulent or low-quality traffic sources.
5
Mid-April
Implemented comprehensive UTM framework and traffic quality monitoring for all paid channels.
Root Cause Identified
Spammy, Unattributed Ad Traffic
After thorough investigation, we identified the precise characteristics of the problematic traffic:
- Missing UTM parameters across all sessions
- Unclassifiable by GA4's standard attribution model
- Highly consistent with bot or automated click patterns
- Strongly correlated with Performance Max and branded search campaigns
- Zero downstream engagement or conversion activity
- Appeared as legitimate paid traffic in ad platform reports
Immediate Fixes
1
Created Segmented Reporting Views
Isolated "(not set)" traffic in all dashboards and reports to prevent data contamination and restore accurate performance visibility.
2
Paused Problematic Campaigns
Immediately halted Performance Max and certain brand campaigns identified as primary sources of low-quality traffic.
3
Implemented Strict UTM Protocol
Enforced comprehensive UTM tagging across all paid channels with automated validation to ensure 100% tracking compliance.
4
Verified Traffic Quality Restoration
Confirmed that legitimate user behavior had resumed normal patterns with bounce rates returning to historical benchmarks of 30-50%.
Future Safeguards: Never Let Dirty Traffic Lie Again
Universal UTM Framework
Implemented mandatory UTM parameters for all traffic sources with automated validation before campaign launch. Standardized naming conventions ensure complete tracking coverage.
Campaign Testing Protocol
Established incremental testing process for all new campaign types, especially automation-heavy formats like Performance Max, with traffic quality gates before scaling.
Automated Alert System
Deployed GA4 and Data Studio alerts for bounce rate spikes, "(not set)" session increases, or any attribution anomalies, with slack notifications to the analytics team.
Segmented Analytics Views
Created separate "clean traffic only" dashboard views that automatically filter suspicious patterns, ensuring decision-makers always see reliable metrics.
Final Result: Data Restored, Savings Realized
42%
Bounce Rate Reduction
From artificially inflated 70%+ to legitimate 40-45% range across all core landing pages
100%
Attribution Accuracy
Restored complete visibility into true campaign performance and user journey tracking
$120K+
Annual Ad Savings
Eliminated wasteful spend on bot traffic and ineffective campaign formats
3X
ROAS Improvement
True conversion attribution revealed much higher return on remaining ad spend
"The fix wasn't the site. It was the signal. Bad traffic = bad data = bad spend."
Ready for More?
Explore my portfolio of case studies and discover more success stories.